Best Costa Rican coffee beans Andrew's Favorite Microlot from Chutas Farm

Best Costa Rican Coffee Beans: Why a Named Farm Beats a Country on the Label

The best Costa Rican coffee beans are fresh, high-scoring, and traceable to a named farm and mill. This guide explains honey process, how to read a Costa Rican coffee label, and how to choose between a silky single-estate lot, a juicy blend, and a rare Mokka or Geisha.

Best Costa Rican coffee beans Andrew's Favorite Microlot from Chutas Farm

Best Costa Rican Coffee Beans: Why a Named Farm Beats a Country on the Label

Best Costa Rican coffee beans Andrew's Favorite Microlot from Chutas Farm

Best Costa Rican coffee beans are traceable to a farm, a mill, and a family. Fresh roasted coffee beans online from Tarrazú, roasted to order.

Here is the truth from a roaster: "Costa Rican coffee" on a bag tells you almost nothing. Costa Rica is a country, not a farm. Plenty of stale, forgettable coffee has that name on it.

The best Costa Rican coffee beans come from small, high-scoring farms, and they have names on them. A farm. A variety. A mill. A score. And they are roasted close to the day you order them.

I roast to order at I Prefer Craft Coffee, and some of my favorite lots come from my friend Pablo's family in Tarrazú. In this guide, I will show you how to read a Costa Rican coffee label, what honey process means, and which of my coffees to try first.

Fast Answer

The best Costa Rican coffee beans are fresh, high-scoring, and traceable to a named farm and mill. My top pick is Andrew's Favorite Microlot: a single-estate honey-processed Red Catuai from Chutas Farm in Tarrazú, scored 86.25, $41.99 for a 10 oz bag. For something rare, try Single Estate Mokka Honey or Single Estate Geisha Honey.

Best for: home brewers who want silky, sweet, and juicy coffee without bitterness.

The Proof

Most people pick Costa Rican coffee by the country. That is the mistake.

  • A country is not a source. "Costa Rica" can mean any farm, any year, and any roast date.
  • A pretty bag is not proof. If there is no roast date, you cannot tell how old the coffee is.
  • Traceability is information. A farm, a variety, an altitude, and a score let you check what you are buying.

What I can show you:

  • My friend Pablo's family grows the Costa Rican coffee in my Microlot, Mokka, and Geisha. His father, Jesús Montero, farms Finca Los Chutas. His uncle, Juan Rafael Montero, farms Finca Monteroga. Both farms are in Tarrazú, in Costa Rica's Los Santos region.
  • Every lot from both farms is processed at Juan's own micromill, Tío Juan. That is two farms, one mill, and one family.
  • The Monteros work almost entirely in single varieties, mostly Catuai and Caturra. Their Red Catuai scored 86.25.
  • My Single Estate Geisha Honey is Q-Graded Outstanding, 90/100.
  • Every bag is roasted to order, small-batch clean-roasted, packed fresh, and marked with a roast date. Over 5,000 bags have shipped from I Prefer Craft Coffee.
  • None of my coffees have added flavors. Berry, chocolate, and brownie notes come from the coffee itself.
  • Traceability here is not a certification, and I do not claim one. My relationship with the Montero family is personal.

My Promise To You

By the end, you will know how to read a Costa Rican coffee bag, what to ask before you buy, and which coffee fits your taste and your budget.

Buy Real Costa Rican Coffee in Six Steps

Costa Rican coffee traced from Tarrazú farm to micromill

Step 1: Look for the Farm, Not Just the Country

What to do: Check whether the bag names a farm. Why it works: A named farm is something you can check. A country is not. See Best Single Origin Coffee Beans. If X, then Y: If the bag lists only "Costa Rica," treat it as a mystery. Example: "Finca Los Chutas, Tarrazú" tells you more than "Costa Rican blend."

Step 2: Follow the Chain From Farm to Mill

What to do: Look for who grew it and where it was processed. Why it works: In my case, it is short. Two farms, one micromill, one family. Read more in What Is Direct Trade Coffee?. If X, then Y: If you cannot find the mill or the producer, ask the seller. Example: The Microlot grew at Chutas Farm and was honey processed by Jesús Montero.

Step 3: Check the Variety and the Process

What to do: Look for the variety (such as Red Catuai) and the process (washed, natural, or honey). Why it works: They explain the taste. Honey process leaves some of the fruit's sticky layer on the bean while it dries. It usually gives a sweet, silky cup. No honey is added. If X, then Y: If you want sweet and silky, choose honey process. Example: All of my Costa Rican coffees are honey processed.

Step 4: Check the Altitude and the Score

What to do: Look for the altitude and the Q score. Why it works: Together they show how the coffee was graded. The Microlot grew at 1,650 m and scored 86.25. If X, then Y: If a bag gives no score, you cannot tell how it was rated. Example: My Geisha is Q-Graded Outstanding at 90/100, grown at 1,850 m.

Step 5: Choose by the Cup You Want

What to do: Pick silky, juicy, lower-priced, or rare. Why it works: You will finish the bag only if you like how it tastes. See Is Specialty Coffee Worth the Price?. If X, then Y: If you want silky, choose the Microlot. If you want juicy, choose Costa Rican Dreams. If you want a rare treat, choose the Mokka or the Geisha. Example: My Costa Rican Dreams blends the Microlot with a second Costa Rican honey coffee. Read the full story in Costa Rican Coffee Blend.

Step 6: Brew It Simply and Store It Sealed

What to do: Use about 15 g of coffee per 240 g of water (1:16). Grind fresh. Use water at 195 to 205°F. Why it works: A steady recipe lets the coffee do the work. Use my coffee-to-water ratio calculator. If X, then Y: If it tastes bitter, grind coarser. If it tastes sour or thin, grind a little finer. Example: Keep the bag sealed in a cool, dark cupboard. See How to Store Coffee Beans Properly.

Which Costa Rican Coffee Fits You?

Tap what sounds like your cup.

Compare My Costa Rican Coffees

Fresh roasted Costa Rican coffee beans from I Prefer Craft Coffee
Coffee Farm Process Altitude Score Price
Andrew's Favorite Microlot Finca Los Chutas, Tarrazú Honey 1,650 m 86.25 $41.99
Costa Rican Dreams Microlot plus a second Costa Rican honey coffee Honey 1,500 to 1,650 m 86.25 $39.99
Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB Hacienda La Amistad, Coto Brus Honey 1,200 to 1,600 m 85/100 $34.99
Single Estate Mokka Honey Finca Monteroga, Tarrazú Honey 1,900 m 89/100 $58.99 for 8 oz
Single Estate Geisha Honey Finca Monteroga, Tarrazú Honey 1,850 m 90/100 from $59.99 for 8 oz

Prices are per 10 oz bag unless noted. A 10 oz bag is about 283 g, roughly 18 mugs at 15 g per mug. An 8 oz bag is about 227 g, roughly 15 mugs. That makes the Microlot about $2.33 a mug, Costa Rican Dreams about $2.22, and Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB about $1.94.

Compare Traceable Costa Rican Coffee With Label-Only Coffee


Traceable, roasted to order Label-only "Costa Rican" coffee
Source Named farm and mill Often just a country
Roast date On the bag Often missing
Variety and process Listed Often missing
Altitude and score Listed where I have them Often missing
Flavor Sweet, silky, clear Often flat or bitter
Added flavors None Varies
Risk Needs you to order An old bag with a nice label

Buying Guidance: How to Choose Costa Rican Coffee

Roast date vs best-by date. A roast date shows real freshness. See Coffee Beans With a Roast Date.

Roast level. The Microlot, Costa Rican Dreams, and Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB come in light, medium, and medium-dark. My Mokka and Geisha are medium roasts. Not sure which to pick? Read my Best Light Roast Coffee Beans guide.

Single estate vs blend. The Microlot is single estate. Costa Rican Dreams is a blend of two Costa Rican honey coffees.

Whole bean vs ground. Whole bean stays fresher. Choose ground if you do not own a grinder.

Brew method. Pour-over shows the most clarity. French press makes a fuller, sweeter cup. Drip is easy and steady.

Storage. Sealed, cool, and dark. My bags have a one-way degassing valve, an inert gas flush, a resealable closure, and a metallized barrier.

Why fresh, high-scoring, traceable coffee wins. The label can be checked against the cup.

Which Costa Rican Coffee Should You Start With?

If You Want... Start Here
A silky, chocolatey treat ($41.99) Andrew's Favorite Microlot
A juicy, fruity blend ($39.99) Costa Rican Dreams
A lower price with guava and brown sugar ($34.99) Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB
A rare Mokka ($58.99 for 8 oz) Single Estate Mokka Honey
A rare Geisha (from $59.99 for 8 oz) Single Estate Geisha Honey
A bag roasted to match your taste (from $34.99, free shipping) Andrew's Better Morning Starter Bag

Prices are per 10 oz bag unless noted. You can also read my Tarrazú Microlot guide, my Mokka guide, my Geisha guide, learn more about your roaster, Andrew, or see how fresh roasted coffee beans online work.

FAQ What Are The Best Costa Rican Coffee Beans?

What are the best Costa Rican coffee beans? The best Costa Rican coffee beans are fresh, high-scoring, and traceable to a named farm and mill. My top pick is Andrew's Favorite Microlot, a single-estate honey-processed Red Catuai from Chutas Farm in Tarrazú that scored 86.25 and is $41.99 for a 10 oz bag.

Where do your Costa Rican coffees come from? My Microlot, Mokka Honey, and Geisha Honey come from the Montero family's two farms in Tarrazú, in Costa Rica's Los Santos region: Finca Los Chutas and Finca Monteroga. All of them are processed at the family's micromill, Tío Juan. My Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB comes from Hacienda La Amistad, a family estate in the Coto Brus highlands.

What is honey process coffee? Honey process means some of the sticky fruit layer stays on the bean while it dries. It usually gives a sweet, silky cup. No honey is added, and nothing else is added either.

Is your Costa Rican coffee certified or fair trade? I do not claim any certification. Traceability here means information you can read, such as the farm, the mill, the variety, the altitude, and the score. My relationship with the Montero family is personal.

What is a good Costa Rican coffee for beginners? Andrew's Favorite Microlot is the one I hand to people who tell me they do not like coffee. It is silky, with a chocolate body and juicy berry underneath. Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB is a good lower-priced start at $34.99.

Do your Costa Rican coffees come in a light roast? Andrew's Favorite Microlot, Costa Rican Dreams, and Organic Costa Rica Honey SHB come in light, medium, and medium-dark. My Single Estate Mokka Honey and Single Estate Geisha Honey are medium roasts.

Do any of your coffees have added flavors? No. None of my coffees have added flavors. Berry, chocolate, and brownie notes come from the coffee itself, and honey process does not mean honey is added.

Are all sales final? Yes, all sales are final, so choose with care. If you are unsure, start with Andrew's Favorite Microlot or the Starter Bag.

PS: Look at the coffee bag in your cupboard. If it says only "Costa Rica," you have just learned what it is not telling you.

Back to blog