September 16, 2024 4 min read

How to Choose the Right Specialty Coffee Beans (And Avoid Bean Regret)

Ever stare at rows of coffee bags, wondering if you’re about to choose the coffee equivalent of cardboard? You’re not alone. But don't worry—choosing the best specialty coffee beans doesn’t require a PhD in caffeine (though, wouldn't that be fun?). With a few simple tips, you'll be sipping on the best tasting craft coffee at home in no time.

So, how do you choose the right beans? Let's break it down into four key factors: origin, roast level, tasting notes, and freshness. Here’s your coffee compass to make sure you never end up with a brew that tastes like a burnt campfire.

1. Origin: Where in the World is Your Coffee From?

Coffee isn’t just “coffee”—it’s a globe-trotting adventure. The origin of your beans plays a huge role in the flavor profile. Think of it like a wine region, but way more energizing (and less likely to make you fall asleep by 4 PM).

  • Central and South America: Expect smooth, balanced flavors. It’s like the cool, dependable friend who always brings snacks to the party. Perfect for beginners.
  • Africa: If you love a fruity and vibrant cup, beans from Ethiopia and Kenya will deliver those complex flavors that’ll make you go, "Wow, is this coffee or a berry smoothie?"
  • Asia: Looking for a rich, earthy cup with a bit of spice? Indonesian beans (Sumatra, anyone?) give you deep, bold flavors perfect for those who like their coffee strong and moody.

Pro Tip: Try a coffee subscription for the best coffee bean delivery that lets you explore different regions without leaving your couch.

2. Roast Level: Light, Medium, or Dark?

Choosing the right roast level is like picking the mood for your coffee—do you want bright and sunny or rich and cozy?

  • Light Roast: For those who want to taste the beans’ origin, light roast is your jam. It's like a morning hike: fresh, energetic, and full of surprises (hopefully good ones).
  • Medium Roast: Balanced, like your favorite sweater—warm but not too heavy. This is where most "top coffee" blends live, offering a good mix of origin flavor and roast influence.
  • Dark Roast: Bold, smoky, and sometimes a little brooding, like your high school poetry phase. Great for people who want something powerful, but be aware: too dark, and you will lose those unique flavors you paid for, which is why we stick to a Medium/Dark profile for darker roasts.

Pro Tip: If you're new to specialty coffee, start with a medium roast. It’s like a friendly handshake instead of a caffeine slap in the face.

3. Tasting Notes: What Do You Really Want in Your Cup?

Tasting notes are like a cheat sheet for what your coffee will taste like. They're those fancy-sounding words like chocolate, berry, floral, and even honeycomb that let you know what to expect.

  • Love chocolatey, nutty flavors? Look for coffees from Central America or Brazil. These beans are like the cozy sweater of coffee: comforting and familiar.
  • Want something fruity and floral? African coffees (especially Ethiopian) will give you those bright, fruity & tea-like notes with a zing. Your taste buds will be in for a treat.
  • Craving something bold and intense? Dark roasts and Indonesian beans offer earthy, spicy tones with a full-bodied feel.

Pro Tip: Don’t be afraid to experiment with different flavor profiles! Order coffee online from a trusted roaster and explore different notes—you might find yourself surprisingly obsessed with a fruity Kenyan blend.

4. Freshness: The Secret Sauce to Your Perfect Cup

Newsflash: coffee isn’t meant to sit on a shelf forever. Freshness is key to brewing the best craft coffee at home. Fresh beans retain their oils and flavors, which means a way better brew.

  • Roast Date Over “Best By” Date: When ordering coffee online, look for roasters that proudly display the roast date. If it’s more than a few weeks old, pass. The best coffee delivered to your doorstep should be roasted within a week or two, tops!
  • Store Your Beans Correctly: Once you’ve got your hands on some fresh beans, store them in an airtight container in a cool, dark place. And please, for the love of coffee, don’t freeze them—coffee isn’t ice cream (unless you plan on keeping them at room temperature until you finish the beans).

Pro Tip: For ultimate freshness, find a coffee roaster that offers same-day shipping or fast delivery. Fresh beans + fast delivery = coffee heaven. P.S. keep the beans in the bag they came in, just press all of the oxygen out of the bag before storing.

Congratulations! You're now equipped to pick the best craft coffee online like a pro. Whether you're hunting for fruity Ethiopian beans or rich, chocolatey Brazilians, knowing your origin, roast level, tasting notes, and the importance of freshness will lead you to the perfect brew. Remember, the right coffee is out there—it’s just waiting for you to order and brew. Now go forth and conquer the coffee aisle at your local coffee spot (or, you know, click "add to cart" and enjoy the best tasting craft coffee at home without leaving your couch).

Happy brewing!

Your buddy Andrew :)